| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| The Prodigal 1914 (Abbey) | Coppinger, Ann | Wednesday, 30 September 1914 |
| The Prodigal 1916 (Abbey) | Drago, Kathleen | Tuesday, 11 January 1916 |
| The Prodigal 1918 (Abbey) | Lynd, Dorothy | Tuesday, 15 January 1918 |
| The Prodigal 1918 (Tour) | Lynd, Dorothy | Wednesday, 6 March 1918 |
| The Prodigal 1919 (Abbey) | O'Malley, Grace | Tuesday, 18 February 1919 |
| The Prodigal 1919 (Abbey) | Craig, May | Tuesday, 16 December 1919 |
| The Prodigal 1923 (Abbey) | Craig, May | Thursday, 15 February 1923 |
