| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| The Casting-out of Martin Whelan 1910 (Abbey) | O'Rourke, J. A. | Thursday, 29 September 1910 |
| The Casting-out of Martin Whelan 1913 (Abbey) | Pelly, Farrell | Thursday, 6 February 1913 |
| The Casting-out of Martin Whelan 1913 (Abbey) | Pelly, Farrell | Thursday, 10 April 1913 |
| The Casting-out of Martin Whelan 1913 (Abbey) | Pelly, Farrell | Thursday, 11 September 1913 |
| The Casting-out of Martin Whelan 1915 (Abbey) | O'Rourke, J. A. | Wednesday, 20 January 1915 |
| The Casting-out of Martin Whelan 1920 (Abbey) | Shields, Arthur | Tuesday, 9 March 1920 |
