| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| The Proposal 1925 (Abbey) | Dolan, Michael J | Tuesday, 28 April 1925 |
| The Proposal 1925 (Abbey) | Dolan, Michael J | Monday, 7 September 1925 |
| The Proposal 1927 (Abbey) | Dolan, Michael J | Monday, 11 July 1927 |
| The Proposal 1936 (Peacock) | Meldon, Austin | Monday, 27 April 1936 |
