| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| Peter 1930 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Tuesday, 28 January 1930 |
| Peter 1930 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Tuesday, 13 May 1930 |
| Peter 1930 (Tour) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 26 May 1930 |
| Peter 1934 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 12 February 1934 |
| Peter 1941 (Abbey) | Johnson, Fred | Monday, 21 July 1941 |
| Peter 1943 (Abbey) | Johnson, Fred | Monday, 8 November 1943 |
| Peter 1944 (Abbey) | Johnson, Fred | Monday, 13 November 1944 |
| Peter 1955 (Abbey) | O Goilidhe (O Goili), Seathrun | Monday, 10 October 1955 |
